WOMEN IN AESTHETIC MEDICINE
PRACTICALLY PERFECT?
As Practical Magic 2 hits cinemas, 28 years after the original, its female stars have ignited a debate around ageing: don’t have too much work done, but don’t show any signs of ageing. Vicky Eldridge asks: how can women in aesthetic medicine help to change the narrative?
I was 19 when Practical Magic came out in 1998 and, in the 28 years since, as you might imagine, I’ve aged. But the fact that its stars, Sandra Bullock and Nicole Kidman, appear not to have aged has been the subject of most of the headlines I’ve seen about the sequel. In fact, I have no idea if it’s any good or not, only that it’s ignited a debate around women and ageing. Again.
I rewatched the original over the summer while feeling unwell. The nostalgia was comforting and made me excited to see the sequel. I love both actresses and enjoyed the witchy, chaotic world of the original. One thing I couldn’t give a hoot about was whether or not they had aged “well”.
But apparently, judging by the coverage I’ve seen, that is what we’re supposed to care about.
With so much going on in the world right now, why can’t we enjoy a bit of escapism on the big screen without dedicating so much column space to debating whether a woman in her 50s and one in her 60s are an affront to feminism because of how they look, or the treatments people assume they have had?
And yes, that did make me question whether I should be writing this at all. Are we challenging the scrutiny or just adding fuel to the fire? When I shared the draft with the WIAM board, that became part of the conversation too.
THE “AGELESSNESS” DEBATE
One of the terms bandied around most during the Practical Magic 2 press tour was “agelessness”, with the two stars being simultaneously criticised and praised for it. Some of the commentary suggested they looked too youthful to be believable – in a film about magic – while other coverage questioned whether celebrating “agelessness” puts pressure on women without a Hollywood budget to look the same.
Once again, it would seem, women are walking the tightrope, being asked not to visibly age or let ourselves go, but not to look like we’ve done anything about it in the process. It would seem we are damned if we do, damned if we don’t.
WHO ACTUALLY CARES?
The Aesthetic Consultant, Vanessa Bird, sees these types of headlines as part of a much longer tradition of commenting on other people’s appearance. “Everyone has an opinion about something at some point”, she says. “People discuss the clothes someone is wearing, how they do their make-up, how they style their hair, whether they are ‘showing off’ by wearing obvious designer labels. Anti-ageing is just another addition to the long list of things people think and/or comment on. It doesn’t make it right. It just makes it human nature.”
And then she adds, “Publishing comments online or in print to encourage discussion is the equivalent of gossiping over the back fence with a neighbour.” And that got me thinking…who really cares? Tracey Dennison, nurse practitioner and founder of The Dennison Clinic, agrees: “Is it a whipped-up media frenzy to create a controversial conversation, or do people actually care?” she says.
"Women are walking the tightrope, being asked not to visibly age or let ourselves go, but not to look like we’ve done anything about it in the process. It would seem we are damned if we do, damned if we don’t."
It’s a fair question. Are patients actually bringing these conversations into clinic, or are we seeing the same headlines repeated until they start to feel like something everyone is talking about?
WHO MAKES THE RULES?
In an article on this very topic in Allure, contributing editor Danielle Pergament asked: “At what age does wanting to look good stop being self-care and become a crime against feminism?”
At what point did we decide that a woman’s face was evidence of whether she was letting the rest of us down? Surely it’s about individual choice? Although, as we know, with most things involving women’s appearance, it’s rarely that straightforward.
GROWING OLD GRACEFULLY
One turn of phrase I can’t abide is “growing old gracefully”, as if there is a graceful and an ungraceful way to get older, depending on what we choose to do about our faces.
Where exactly is the line between acceptable maintenance and something for which we should apparently feel ashamed? Colouring our hair? Wearing make-up? Having aesthetic treatments?
Women in aesthetic medicine will be familiar with these judgements. We work in an industry that offers people choices about their appearance, yet those choices are often discussed as though they tell us everything about a woman’s confidence, intelligence or values.
Having treatment doesn’t mean someone has failed to accept herself. Equally, choosing not to have it doesn’t mean she has given up. Women should be able to make either decision without being turned into an example of how the rest of us ought to behave.
CHALLENGING BEAUTY STANDARDS
That doesn’t mean we can dismiss every concern about beauty standards by saying it’s all personal choice. We can defend a woman’s right to treatment and still ask questions about the pressures that make her feel she needs it.
If the faces we celebrate are always youthful, what are we saying about everyone else? If “you haven’t aged a day” is the highest compliment we can offer, it’s hardly surprising that getting older starts to feel like something we should conceal.
Celebrity images also come with a context that is easily forgotten when we compare ourselves with them. Lighting, styling, make-up, photography and the resources available to someone whose appearance is part of their professional life all matter. A red-carpet photograph is hardly a fair benchmark for how the rest of us should look on a Tuesday morning walking the dog, taking the kids to school or opening up clinic.
The difficulty is discussing that context without making yet another woman’s face the subject of an investigation. We don’t need to establish what Kidman or Bullock may have had done to recognise that the expectations placed on women are exhausting.
CHANGING OUR OWN LANGUAGE
So how do we bring this back to aesthetic medicine? For me, it’s about the language we use to promote what we are doing. “Ageless”, “turn back the clock” and “erase the years” are familiar phrases, but what expectations do they create?
In reality, for many patients it’s not about looking ageless or 20 years younger; it’s about feeling like ourselves again.
Changing the narrative might mean showing a wider range of ages in clinic marketing and asking patients what they want rather than assuming they want to look younger. It also means being careful not to turn every visible sign of ageing into something that needs treating.
Bird raises another question: Should practitioners discuss celebrities on their social media and the work they have had done? Is it truly educational or just for clickbait?
A familiar face might get people watching, but what are we asking them to watch for? There is a difference between explaining a treatment and picking apart someone’s appearance to suggest what they may have had done.
If we are questioning the scrutiny that must include our own content. Women in aesthetic medicine have an opportunity to bring more honesty and less judgement to this discussion, whether that is in a consultation, in our marketing or when we’re tempted to join the latest celebrity conversation online.
"Should practitioners discuss celebrities on their social media and the work they have had done? Is it truly educational or just for clickbait?"
We understand that treatment choices are personal and that confidence is rarely as straightforward as a before-and-after photograph suggests. This is why I am excited to see aesthetics evolving beyond the needle, with more attention paid to skin health, wellbeing and what patients actually want from treatment.
Dennison agrees. “It’s more important that people are happy and healthy, but part of being happy and healthy is often reflected in appearance”, she says.
I am still looking forward to seeing Practical Magic 2. I’m hoping to escape the world for a few hours watching two great actresses recreate characters I loved as a teen, without their faces becoming a referendum on feminism. When it comes to my own face, I’d like the freedom to get older in whichever way I choose, without feeling that choice is a reflection on womanhood as a whole.