BEYOND THE TEMPLATE
Dr Ahmed El Muntasar argues that safe, individualised aesthetic care requires practitioners to understand anatomical variation, assess skin characteristics and question whose beauty standards shape treatment.
One of the fundamental principles of aesthetic medicine is that we treat the patient in front of us rather than work to a template. Yet, in my view, too much of our teaching and practice still centres on white faces and Western beauty standards. When these become the default for every patient, we risk overlooking differences that matter to treatment safety, suitability and the outcome the patient wants.
Understanding a patient’s ethnic background can be a valuable part of an aesthetic consultation, particularly when discussing identity and treatment goals. However, ethnicity is not a substitute for assessing anatomy, skin pigmentation, medical history or individual risk. Two people who share an ethnic background may have very different facial structures, skin characteristics and aesthetic preferences. Ethnicity should inform a conversation, not determine a treatment plan.
UNDERSTANDING ANATOMICAL VARIATION
Facial skeletal morphology, soft-tissue distribution, skin thickness and ageing patterns vary between individuals. Population-level observations can provide context, but broad ethnic categories cannot reliably predict an individual patient’s anatomy. The practical task is to assess the patient’s own midfacial proportions, nasal projection, lower-face structure and soft tissues, rather than assume what those features will be on the basis of heritage.
This becomes particularly important when we consider the concept of facial “idealisation”. There is no single ideal set of facial proportions that should be universally applied. Ratios and measurements can be useful assessment tools, but they should never become targets in themselves. A practitioner who repeatedly attempts to reproduce the same nasal profile, lip ratio or chin projection risks creating results that are technically proficient but aesthetically incongruous with the patient’s underlying anatomy. A non-surgical rhinoplasty, for example, should not automatically aim to produce the same narrow, highly projected nasal profile in every patient. Likewise, lip augmentation should not be based upon one universal lip ratio. The aim should be harmony within the individual patient’s face.
Social media has made this conversation even more relevant. Beauty trends now travel across borders almost instantaneously, and patients may arrive in my London clinic with reference photographs from Seoul, Los Angeles, Lagos or Dubai. There is nothing inherently wrong with patients taking inspiration from another person’s appearance, but our role as clinicians is not simply to reproduce a photograph. We have to consider whether the requested feature is compatible with the patient’s anatomy and whether it is clinically appropriate, achievable and consistent with the patient’s goals. A face-to-face assessment gives us the opportunity to examine anatomy, discuss expectations and explain the limitations and risks of treatment.
SKIN OF COLOUR AND CLINICAL RISK
Skin pigmentation is a separate clinical consideration. Postinflammatory hyperpigmentation is an important risk in more deeply pigmented skin when planning procedures that cause inflammation or injury. Lasers, intense pulsed light and chemical peels require an assessment of the patient’s skin characteristics, treatment history and individual risk. The nature and extent of that risk depend on the procedure and how it is delivered.
This does not mean that patients with darker skin cannot receive energy-based treatments; that misconception can itself lead to inequity in aesthetic care. Instead, practitioners need to understand appropriate device selection, wavelengths, treatment parameters, cooling strategies and pre- and post-procedure care. A practitioner who is confident treating Fitzpatrick skin types I and II should not automatically assume that the same protocol can be transferred unchanged to Fitzpatrick types V or VI. The Fitzpatrick scale describes the skin’s tendency to burn or tan in response to sunlight; it is not a classification of ethnicity or a complete assessment of procedural risk. Equally, a history of post-inflammatory pigmentation, hypertrophic scarring or keloid formation should be explored where clinically relevant before performing procedures that disrupt the skin.
This is an important distinction because treating everybody identically is not necessarily the same as treating everybody equally. Good medicine has always involved adjusting our approach according to the characteristics and risk profile of the patient. We would not use an identical medical treatment irrespective of age, anatomy, comorbidities or individual risk factors, and aesthetic medicine should be no different.
"Our role is not to decide which aspects of somebody’s identity they should preserve."
PRESERVING IDENTITY RATHER THAN IMPOSING AN AESTHETIC IDEAL
Perhaps the most nuanced aspect of ethnically appropriate aesthetic medicine is the relationship between treatment and identity. As practitioners, we need to be conscious of the possibility that aesthetic medicine can unintentionally homogenise appearance. If every nose is made narrower, every chin more projected and every pair of lips treated towards the same ratio, we should question whether we are genuinely individualising treatment or simply reproducing one aesthetic standard across different faces.
This does not mean that features associated with a patient’s ethnic heritage should be considered untouchable. Patients have autonomy over their appearance and may specifically wish to alter a characteristic that is associated with their familial or ethnic background. Our role is not to decide which aspects of somebody’s identity they should preserve. Our responsibility is to ensure that the decision is theirs rather than something unconsciously directed by the practitioner’s own perception of what constitutes an attractive face.
For this reason, I believe some of the most important work in aesthetic medicine happens before a syringe is opened. A good consultation should explore not only what the patient wants changed, but what they do not want changed. Which features do they particularly like? Which aspects of their appearance make them feel like themselves? What does a “natural” result mean to them? Are they asking for greater definition, rejuvenation or a fundamental change in facial shape? Understanding those distinctions allows us to build a treatment plan around the patient’s own aesthetic identity rather than our own.
Culturally sensitive communication supports informed consent. Concepts such as femininity, masculinity, youthfulness, facial shape and even what constitutes an obviously “treated” appearance can vary significantly between individuals and cultures. Language matters too. A practitioner might describe reducing lower-face width as “facial slimming”, for example, but a facial characteristic regarded as undesirable within one aesthetic framework may be regarded as attractive or culturally significant within another. We should approach these conversations with curiosity rather than assumptions, while discussing the benefits, risks, alternatives and option of no treatment.
OUR TRAINING NEEDS TO REFLECT OUR PATIENTS
If we expect practitioners to treat a diverse population safely and sensitively, our education needs to reflect that population. It is difficult to become genuinely competent across different skin types and facial anatomies if training materials predominantly demonstrate one type of face or skin.
The same scrutiny should be applied to the evidence underpinning the products and technologies we use. When considering a new laser, injectable or energy-based device, practitioners should be asking who was represented in the clinical studies. Were a range of Fitzpatrick skin types included? Were outcomes and adverse events adequately evaluated across different populations? Do we have sufficient evidence to confidently extrapolate those findings to the patient sitting in front of us? Where evidence is limited, that uncertainty should form part of our clinical judgement rather than being ignored.
This is also particularly pertinent as artificial intelligence, automated facial analysis and digital consultation tools become more common within aesthetic practice. We should be careful not to allow algorithms to give subjective beauty standards the appearance of scientific objectivity. Technology trained on insufficiently diverse populations has the potential to reinforce existing aesthetic biases rather than eliminate them.
"Our patients should never have to fit the treatment. The treatment should fit the patient."
A MATTER OF CLINICAL RESPONSIBILITY
Ultimately, ethnically appropriate aesthetic medicine is not simply a conversation about diversity or representation; it is a question of clinical competence. Aesthetic medicine does not sit outside the principles that govern the rest of medical practice. We still have a responsibility to assess appropriately, understand individual risk, communicate honestly, practise within the limits of our competence and put the patient’s interests first.
Doctors have a professional responsibility to recognise and work within the limits of their competence. If a practitioner has extensive experience treating lighter skin types but limited experience using a particular laser in deeply melanised skin, the appropriate response is not to assume that the same protocol will suffice. It may be necessary to undertake further training, seek advice from a more experienced colleague or refer the patient. Recognising the limits of our expertise is not a weakness; it is an essential component of safe medical practice.
The future of aesthetic medicine should not be one in which every patient gradually moves towards the same face. The most sophisticated aesthetic work is often the work that respects what is already there: understanding the patient’s anatomy, appreciating the biology of their skin, recognising the cultural context in which they view their appearance and making considered interventions that preserve individuality.
Ethnically appropriate treatment does not mean treating patients according to their ethnicity. It means recognising when heritage is relevant to the consultation, assessing anatomy and skin characteristics directly, and incorporating that information into an individualised plan.
Our patients should never have to fit the treatment. The treatment should fit the patient.
DR AHMED EL MUNTASAR
Dr Ahmed El Muntasar is an NHS GP and award-winning aesthetic doctor, and founder of The Aesthetics Doctor. Having qualified in medicine at the University of Manchester and completed a Master’s in Medical Leadership at UCL, his approach combines clinical rigour, ethical practice and personalised patient care.