VOICES
THE PURSUIT OF EXPERTISE OR THE PURSUIT OF RECOGNITION?
Amy Bird questions whether aesthetic medicine is prioritising visibility and recognition over clinical knowledge.
CHASING THE SHINY LIGHTS
There is something about the direction of medical aesthetics that increasingly troubles me. We seem to have developed an insatiable appetite for what comes next.
The latest injectable. The newest technique. The next masterclass. The next stage appearance. The next opportunity to become an educator, brand ambassador or key opinion leader.
And somewhere amongst all these shiny lights, I worry that we are losing sight of the very foundations upon which credible clinical practice should be built.
Anatomy, for example, is not a subject to be ticked off during initial training before progressing to something more exciting. It is a discipline that demands continual study, critical thinking and an appreciation of just how much we may not yet understand.
Yet I increasingly question whether the enthusiasm for learning the latest injection technique is always matched by the enthusiasm for understanding the anatomical structures that underpin it.
We must distinguish between learning how to replicate a technique and developing the knowledge required to make an independent, anatomically informed clinical decision.
WHEN INFLUENCE BECOMES THE GOAL
There is another dimension to this culture of progression that deserves scrutiny. When did becoming a key opinion leader become an aspiration in its own right, rather than recognition that follows a demonstrable contribution to the profession?
There appears to be a growing fascination with becoming the face of a brand, standing on a conference stage, joining a ‘faculty’ or being recognised as an industry expert.
There is nothing inherently wrong with these ambitions. These platforms can create meaningful opportunities to teach, collaborate and contribute to industry education.
However, I will add that I have never chased them. They were opportunities presented to me after years of self-investment and hard graft, and I can assure you there are also many I have turned down. Why? I value my credibility and my standards and while the shiny lights are fun, they don’t help me sleep at night.
ARE WE CHASING EXPERTISE, OR ARE WE CHASING THE APPEARANCE OF EXPERTISE?
I often question whether we are clear about the distinction between wanting to be recognised as an expert and doing the work required to become one.
Teaching requires its own knowledge, skills and accountability. It requires an understanding of educational methodology, learner assessment, clinical governance and the responsibility of influencing how others practise.
Perhaps most importantly, it requires the humility to recognise that being knowledgeable in one area does not make us an authority in every other.
THE DUNNING–KRUGER EFFECT
The Dunning-Kruger effect is a cognitive bias where people with limited knowledge in an area overestimate their own competence, whereas, high performers may underestimate their skills.
The concept raises questions about our ability to accurately evaluate our own competence, particularly when we lack the knowledge needed to recognise our limitations.
I am not suggesting that every ambitious or highly visible practitioner overestimates their abilities. But I do wonder whether a culture that rewards confidence and visibility can sometimes make meaningful self-assessment less attractive than self-promotion.
How often do we seek independent assessment of our clinical competence, welcome genuine scrutiny of our decisions or acknowledge that others may have greater expertise in a particular area?
These are questions I also ask myself. Experience, qualifications and professional positions should never make any of us immune to scrutiny.
"We should be developing educators who create independent thinkers, not simply confident imitators."
WHAT MAKES AN EXPERT?
I also believe industry has a responsibility here. If we position individuals as educational authorities, we should be able to articulate the criteria for selecting them.
Clinical expertise, evidence literacy, educational competence, professional integrity and critical thinking should matter.
Visibility and commercial appeal may be valuable attributes, but they cannot substitute for these foundations. We should be developing educators who create independent thinkers, not simply confident imitators.
Perhaps we need to reconsider how we measure professional success. Is it by the brands we represent, the conferences we speak at or the titles we hold?
Or should success be measured by the depth of our knowledge, the soundness of our clinical judgement, the outcomes we deliver and the skills we help others develop?
There will always be something new to learn, a technique to explore or an opportunity to pursue. Innovation is essential to the development of our specialty. But progress without foundations is not necessarily advancement.
Perhaps before asking how we become the next recognised expert, we should be asking whether we have done enough to deserve the responsibility that comes with being considered one.
Because the goal should never be simply to become the person everyone listens to.
It should be to become someone whose knowledge, judgement and integrity make them worth listening to.
Bird’s THE WORD
Every issue, Amy Bird, our aesthetic nurse on the inside, reflects on life within the sector
AMY BIRD
Amy Bird RGN NMP is an award-winning nurse prescriber, speaker, trainer and KOL with more than a decade of full time experience in medical aesthetics. She is lead nurse at her practice, KAST Medical Aesthetics in Cheshire, and recently became chair of BAMAN. She is a passionate advocate for best practice, standards and patient safety.